Award Category
Screenplay Award Category
When a young boy repairs a wrecked boat and sets out to sea, he finds himself on an extraordinary island that is in need of help; but he must choose between staying or finding a way back home.
This submission is private and only visible to judges.
Comments
The start to an exciting MG…
The start to an exciting MG adventure! I think Noah could be written with a bit more of a middle-grade voice- like when we said 'Imminent danger!', it didn't feel like something a kid would say. Overall a great story, just a bit more tweaking on the voice!
Thank you for your feedback…
In reply to The start to an exciting MG… by Holly Davis
Thank you for your feedback. It is greatly appreciated!
A great start that takes us…
A great start that takes us to the inciting incident quickly, but with enough introduction to give the reader clear setting and character. I'd agree about Noah's voice - the 'Gosh' didn't ring true for me.
Thank you for your feedback!…
In reply to A great start that takes us… by Jenni Harrison
Thank you for your feedback! I'll definitely develop Noah's voice to match his age.
A book I'd like to read...
Like the other judges before me, I would agree on the voice, keep Noah's age in mind and the ages of the readers. But Noah and his Father are very likeable and well-described. I think this is a great start to what I hope will be an incredible adventure for middle grade readers. Very good start!
Thank you for your feedback!…
In reply to A book I'd like to read... by Keith Garton
Thank you for your feedback! I appreciate your comments.
I loved it! Great opening…
I loved it! Great opening scene and intriguing follow up. The only situation that raised a red flag for me was the dad's nonchalant reaction to losing his son at the beach, especially after his son has a history of going too far out in the water. As a parent, my immediate thought to losing my kid at a public beach would be that they are either drowning or have been kidnapped. As a reader, I would like to see the father show more concern. Otherwise, this is a great start and I'm excited to see more.
Thank you for your feedback!…
In reply to I loved it! Great opening… by Melissa Hope
Thank you for your feedback! I look forward to focusing on these improvements when I edit the story again.